By Dennis Kellogg
Director of Communications
Margaret Medel of Lincoln recalls vividly the details of that day 70 years ago when she came face to face with the lady in the dumpster.
“I just remember looking up and seeing this pretty face looking at me, and I remember especially I could only see the face, but I remember really noticing the eyes,” Margaret said. “I just stopped and kept staring at her and thinking, “Oh, she’s too pretty to be in that dumpster.”
Margaret was little Margie Geiger back then. The year was 1956 and she was just 10 years old, pushing a stroller with her little brother Danny in it down the alley by the St. Joseph School gymnasium in York, Nebraska. That’s when her eyes met those eyes in the dumpster.
She quickly returned her brother back home, where she got her little red wagon and her mom’s permission to rescue that “lady.” Her mom figured it was a doll someone had tossed aside.
When she returned to the dumpster, she needed the help of a neighbor who was working in his yard to get her out and into the wagon.
“I remember him removing her from the dumpster very slowly, very carefully, actually crawling into the dumpster and lifting her out,” Margaret said.
That’s when Margaret met St. Catherine of Alexandria for the first time.
The four-foot-two statue of the saint had been thrown away and now it was being rescued by a little girl who took it home and told her parents, “I want to paint her and I want to make her more beautiful.”
SNR photos | Natalie Bender
St. Catherine of Alexandria was born in Egypt around 287. At the age of 14, she became a Christian, a dangerous thing to do at the time. Yet, she was able to convert hundreds to the faith. The emperor wanted to marry her if she would renounce her faith. Catherine declined his advances and he ordered her to be executed. She was eventually beheaded and later recognized as a virgin, martyr and saint of the early Church.
Margaret would come to learn all of this through the years as she tried to discover as much as she could about St. Catherine. Her mother would research the saint’s life and share information with Margaret. And the Benedictine Sisters who taught her at St. Joseph also helped her learn more about St. Catherine.
All the while, the statue stood in the basement of the family’s home in York. Margaret would show St. Catherine to friends who would come over to the house.
“I remember as a child in grade school and high school praying to her, sitting in front of her at times and just looking at her, admiring her,” Margaret said.
Her mother saw a stamp on the statue that read “Daprato.” That’s the name of a famous statuary company founded by Italian immigrants in 1860 in Chicago and known for the quality of its work.
Through the years, that Daprato statue of St. Catherine remained in her parents’ basement. Margaret went to college and became a teacher, working in St. Louis, Imperial, Nebraska and Mexico City. She would marry her husband Luciano, who is from Mexico City. They would have two children together and settle in Lincoln.
Margaret never forgot about her statue. Her parents would often ask in phone calls if she wanted them to take the statue somewhere, donate it somewhere. And Margaret would always say no. She assured them she would get St. Catherine when the time was right. For 35 years, the time was never right and the statue remained with her parents.
Then came that Saturday morning in 1991. Around 7:30 a.m., Margaret awakened to someone knocking loudly at the back door of their home. When she got out of bed and opened the door, there stood her parents, looking very solemn and serious.
Her dad finally spoke. “We brought St. Catherine of Alexandria,” he said. And her mom and dad both waited for Margaret’s reaction.
“I was shocked and then I was so happy,” Margaret recalled.
Margaret and her husband and children welcomed St. Catherine into their home.
“Somebody would just pass by and say a little prayer to her,” Margaret said. “I never quit talking about her. I would always share her, show her to relatives, talk about her to cousins who would stop by, to neighbors.”
She took photos of the statue – 45 of them – and placed them in a photo album.
“I always had this concern, always worrying that I never wanted her to be returned to a dumpster ever again.”
People heard about the statue. Antique collectors contacted her. An artist in New York City called and said if she would bring the statue to her, she would restore it and find a good place on the East Coast to donate it.
A man from a statuary company in St. Louis offered to drive to Lincoln and purchase the statue from her. She finally reluctantly agreed, thinking she couldn’t keep it forever. But the night before he was ready to leave, Margaret, with tears rolling down her cheeks, called him to tell him, “’Sorry sir, but I’ve changed my mind. I just can’t sell her. I can’t sell her for money. I just can’t do it.’ It was just so difficult. I wouldn’t let her go.”
Margaret said as she grew older, “there was this little voice telling me… ‘if you don’t make a plan....’ I had this horrible fear I would die, and they would be cleaning out my house, and they would look at the statue and go, ‘Oh my gosh, the paint. She’s chipped in places. Somebody carry her out to the dumpster!’”
Margaret prayed to St. Catherine, asking, as Catholics do, for the saint to intercede on her behalf before God. This time, though, she asked for St. Catherine’s intercession to help her find a new home for the statue. She started making phone calls to restoration companies. She searched for parishes in the Midwest named for St. Catherine of Alexandria. Yet, she couldn’t find a place that seemed to be the right fit for her St. Catherine.
Then someone suggested St. Catherine Parish in Indianola in southwest Nebraska. A parish in her own diocese!
She reached out to the pastor, Father Michael Houlihan.
“I think we’re the only church in the state that’s named after that saint, and I thought this would be fine,” Father Houlihan said. “She did kind of put a proviso on there that we had to have it repaired, and I said, ‘Well, right now I don’t have any funds that I can put aside for that.’”
The local Knights of Columbus council found out about it and said they would contribute toward the restoration. The parish is open to other donations for the project as well.
Margaret knew it would take a special person to restore the statue.
“You just can’t have anybody take a paintbrush to her,” Margaret said. “She really needs to be restored by someone who really understands her historic value, who understands what she’s made of, and who would have the desire to do it out of love.”
Father Houlihan had someone in mind.
“Well, it’s really hard for me to say no when a pastor asks me to do something artistic,” said Sondra Jonson, an accomplished sculptor with a studio in Cambridge, Nebraska. She is a member of St. John the Baptist Parish in Cambridge, just 15 minutes from St. Catherine in Indianola. Her award-winning sculptures can be found throughout the United States and Europe.
This kind of restoration, though, is not something she usually does.
“My pieces are bronzes and so I work in clay,” Jonson said. “We make molds of clay and the molds go to a bronze casting foundry and they go through a number of processes to end up with a bronze. So this (restoration) is nothing like what I do.”
She did work with plaster in art school, however, so she “kind of got to know plaster and I like it,” she said.
The statue itself also attracted Jonson to the project.
“It’s a really good statue, just as a piece of art,” she said. “The quality of the sculpting, the proportions, the fineness of the features, the overall grace is just a very high-quality statue… I can’t understand why it was thrown out to begin with, but underneath all the ravaged paint, it’s a very good sculpture. It’s going to be beautiful.”
With the church selected and the artist chosen to restore the statue, all that was left was for Margaret to give St. Catherine away. That’s something she hadn’t been able to do for 70 years.
On the day Margaret and her husband were preparing to load the statue into their car and drive it to another town to meet Father Houlihan, the skies opened up and the rain fell. A hard rain.
The statue stood at the opening of the garage, just inside so it would not get wet. Margaret’s daughter found out
St. Catherine was leaving for good and she asked them to wait before they left. She drove over from her home in Lincoln. Margaret and Luciano noticed her car in the driveway, but she hadn’t come into the house.
“We open the back door,” Margaret said. “She’s kissing her eyes. I just stood there in disbelief. She said, ‘I’m kissing her eyes one last time. Mother, I’ve always kissed her at times and prayed to her, and there’s something about her eyes.’
“I have to confess, when no one was looking… I had to also give her one last kiss,” Margaret said.
The Medels met Father Houlihan at St. Gregory the Great Seminary in Seward to transfer the statue. Father Daniel Rayer, originally from Indianola, helped transfer and secure the statue.
Sadness set in for Margaret the first couple of weeks after donating the statue. She missed St. Catherine. Then she got a reassuring phone call from Sondra Jonson.
“I will work on her and I will make her beautiful,” Margaret remembered Sondra telling her. “I will restore her like she should be restored.”
Margaret said that phone call made a “huge difference,” giving her “great calmness and peace.”
Jonson hopes she can have the statue restoration complete in 2027, in time for the celebration of the 100th anniversary of St. Catherine Church in Indianola in the fall. Margaret and her husband Luciano are planning to be there. They hope to meet Sondra in person and see her finished work.
“Now when you look at it, mostly you see the ravaged paint peeling and it just looks like a mess,” Jonson said. “But the sculpture is beautiful… Even if you just painted it white, it would be a beautiful sculpture because it’s so beautifully done.”
Father Houlihan thinks he has a good spot for the statue, where it will be seen by parishioners and visitors on a regular basis. He said St. John Damascene reminds us of the value of great art as a part of our faith.
“He’s the one that said because Christ was God become man, we see the image of God in the world,” Father Houlihan said. “And so, any representations certainly are not against the First Commandment, but they remind us of what Christ did when He transformed the world by becoming man and being incarnate.”
In the future, others will get to enjoy the St. Catherine statue Margaret has journeyed with for seven decades. She hopes when they look into those eyes that once stared back at her from a dumpster in an alley, they’ll experience the same peace and joy that St. Catherine has brought to her through the years.
Margaret said she loved learning about St. Catherine of Alexandria. She now hopes more people will learn about her. There is one important lesson in particular that stands out for Margaret.
“Try to live my own life by thinking about what a saint’s life is like and trying to imitate that, to try to grow closer in love to God,” she said. “This life isn’t what’s important, not at all. It’s like a flash of lightning through the sky. It’s the next life that has all the meaning for us and all the value. By always having St. Catherine here, it was a constant reminder. You need to be preparing your soul for the next life in everything you do, think and say. That’s what she meant to me.”